Τὴν ἀρχὴν ὅτι καὶ λαλῶ ὑμῖν
David Lim wrote:From where did you get the idea that there is aspect in the imperative?
Scott Lawson wrote:David,
Be silent, Put the muzzle on and keep it on. σιώπα, πεφίμωσο...Mark 4:39. The action is durative. Be in good health. ἔρρωσο Acts 23:30 Text. Rec.
The perfect imperative is rare in the N.T. and the action is durative.
Scott Lawson wrote:David Lim wrote:From where did you get the idea that there is aspect in the imperative?
David, I don't believe I said aspect.
David Lim wrote:Here you say that the perfect imperative is durative but later you say that it is constative. But nevermind I think it is neither.
David Lim wrote:Yes I mistook your statements, because I do not think lexical aspect (inherent in the verb) can be independent of grammatical aspect (expressed in grammatical syntax), but that grammatical aspect is restricted to such as is permitted by lexical aspect.
Scott Lawson wrote:David Lim wrote:Here you say that the perfect imperative is durative but later you say that it is constative. But nevermind I think it is neither.
Hmmm....I'm not sure who's confused here...Robertson or Smyth. ....
Scott Lawson wrote:Scott Lawson wrote:David Lim wrote:Here you say that the perfect imperative is durative but later you say that it is constative. But nevermind I think it is neither.
Hmmm....I'm not sure who's confused here...Robertson or Smyth. ....
Oh! It just occurred to me that maybe I was confused! Let's go with durative!
Scott Lawson wrote:David Lim wrote:
From where did you get the idea that there is aspect in the imperative?
David, I don't believe I said aspect.
Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot] and 0 guests