John 11:35, You'll see
John M. Moe
John.M.Moe-1 at tc.umn.edu
Mon Jun 22 13:29:20 EDT 1998
dalmatia at eburg.com wrote:
>
SNIP
> As a response, it follows
> everyone saying "Come and see," which interestingly is the same thing
> Jesus said to his first disciples in John in response to their enquiry
> of where Jesus was remaining, which is the same remaining that caused
> the death of Lazarus in the first place...
>
SNIP
Just couldn't let this one pass. In the incident to which your refer, John 1:39, Jesus says ERXESQE
KAI OYESQE. Note, OYESQE is future indicative, not imperative. Now, I know that the future
indicative sometimes is used with volitive force, but here I think we have and invitation in the
imperative, ERXESQE, followed by a promise in the indicative OYESQE. "Come and you'll see"
contrasted to the challenge issued to the skeptical Nathaniel a few verses latter, ERXOU KAI IDE.
I think there is a contrast, not a parallel, between the ERXOU KAI IDE of John 11:34 and the ERXESQE
KAI OYESQE to the two disciples of John at John 1:39.
--
Rev. John M. Moe
St. John's Lutheran Church, Rich Valley
http://www.state.net/sjrv/
More information about the B-Greek
mailing list