Galatians 2:20
Eric Weiss
eweiss at gte.net
Fri Apr 2 13:39:06 EST 1999
A couple more thoughts or questions re: this verse.
What kind of "EN" are we dealing with in EN PISTEI? A skim-through (without
a Greek concordance, unfortunately!) seems to show that when Paul means one
lives "by" or "through" faith (i.e., instrumental), he uses EK PISTEWS or,
less often, DIA PISTEWS. I couldn't find another EN PISTEI in my brief
run-through (except I Timothy 1:2, which is a different usage).
Does he use EN here because he just used EN in EN SARKI, though he means an
instrumental dative? I.e., "But [or: And] in that [or: but the life that] I
now am living with reference to the [or: in this] flesh (i.e., dative of
sphere or reference), I am living by [means of] faith ..."
(I take "flesh" here to have the negative connotations it has elsewhere in
this epistle, as opposed to simply meaning "living in a body" - any
thoughts on that?)
OR - is EN PISTEI, like EN SARKI, likewise a dative of reference or sphere,
i.e., "But in that I now am living in this flesh, I am living in the sphere
of faith - the Son of God's faith [who lives in me]"
I hope I'm not making a mountain out of a molehill.
On 04/02/99, "Carlton Winbery <winberyc at popalex1.linknet.net>" wrote:
>
> I would say that the only difference the "THi" makes is to make sure the
> reader knows that TOU hUIOU TOU QEOU modifies PISTEI, i.e. the article is
> used to show the grammatical relationship of the later phrase. It could
> have been written "...EN PISTEI TOU hUIOU TOU QEOU ZW..." and would mean
> the same thing.
>
> The question as to whether TOU hUIOU is subjective or objective genitive
> has been debated at least twice on this list. I would tend to agree with
> those who see Paul's use in such passages as objective genitive, but the
> argumentation is mostly a question of Pauline theology.
>
>
> Carlton L. Winbery
> Fogleman Professor of Religion
> Louisiana College
> Pineville, LA 71359
> winberyc at popalex1.linknet.net
> winbery at andria.lacollege.edu
More information about the B-Greek
mailing list