Mk 8:35-37, YUCH
Joe A. Friberg
JoeFriberg at email.msn.com
Sat Dec 18 22:31:01 EST 1999
Paul Dixon wrote:
> Surely one would think that in the same immediate context the nuance of
> YUCH would
> be the same, but rendering it as life in v. 35, then as soul in verses 36
> and 37 seems
> to suggest otherwise.
In v35, YUCH is something that can be both lost and saved at the same time;
hence there are two levels or types of YUCH referenced in this verse:
- a lower and higher life, or
- temporal vs. eternal life, or
- present life only vs. life continuing to afterlife.
This alternation is in itself a play on words. We do not use the term
'soul' in such a bifurcated manner, but as an indivisible organic whole,
possessing continuity. Hence none of the translations cited have used
'soul' in this verse.
In v36-37, YUXH is limited to the second category found in v35: the
higher/eternal life. When viewed in continuity with the current life, this
is closer to our wholistic conception of 'soul', which is why a number of
translations choose to switch to this term at this point.
Note that the contrast is not between vv36-37 and v35, but is found within
v35 itself, while v36-37 merely settle on one of the senses found in v35.
God Bless!
Joe A. Friberg
More information about the B-Greek
mailing list