1 Peter 2:19

John M. Harkins smichael at bellatlantic.net
Wed Jun 9 08:04:28 EDT 1999




John Barach wrote:

> I've been working on 1 Peter 2:18-20 and have run into the difficult
> phrase in 2:19:  DIA SUNEIDHSIN QEOU.  My question is twofold:
>
> (1) First, how should SUNEIDESIN QEOU be understood?
>
> Most often in the NT, the word SUNEIDHSIS refers to the conscience as a
> source of moral awareness.  Consequently, this phrase is sometimes
> rendered "because of a [good] conscience toward God."  The problem with
> that rendering, however, is that the word "good" does not appear in most
> manuscripts and it seems awkward or implausible to render the genitive
> QEOU as "toward" or "with reference to God."
>
> SUNEIDHSIS can also be rendered as "consciousness," as several
> commentaries suggest.  Such a translation fits better with the genitive:
> "because of consciousness of God."  On the whole, the two translations
> are not that distant in meaning:  being conscious of God (i.e., aware of
> His presence, His standards, His evaluation) will lead the believer to
> strive for a good conscience before Him.
>
> (2) My second question concerns the function of the prepositional phrase.
>  Most often, the passage has been taken to mean that the believer who is
> suffering endures his sorrows patiently because he is conscious of God
> (or has a good conscience toward God) and because he knows that God is
> the ultimate and righteous judge, and so forth.
>
> Some (e.g., Goppelt, Van Houwelingen) understand DIA SUNEIDHSIS QEOU to
> be the *basis* or *origin* of the unjust suffering.  "Christians have to
> suffer above all on account of their conscience which is trained on God
> and remains bound to him," Van Houwelingen says, citing Goppelt.
>
> Any help you could provide would be greatly appreciated.
>
> Thanks!
>
> John
>
> %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
> John Barach
> Box 295, Lethbridge, AB  T1J 3Y7
> Ministerial Candidate (URCNA)
>
> %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
> John Barach
> Box 295, Lethbridge, AB  T1J 3Y7
> Ministerial Candidate (URCNA)
>
> ___________________________________________________________________
> Get the Internet just the way you want it.
> Free software, free e-mail, and free Internet access for a month!
> Try Juno Web: http://dl.www.juno.com/dynoget/tagj.
>
> ---
> B-Greek home page: http://sunsite.unc.edu/bgreek
> You are currently subscribed to b-greek as: smichael at bellatlantic.net
> To unsubscribe, forward this message to $subst('Email.Unsub')
> To subscribe, send a message to subscribe-b-greek at franklin.oit.unc.edu

1 PT 2: 19
TOUTO GAR XARIS EI DIA SUNEIDHSIN QEOU hUPOFEREI TIS LUPAS PASXWN ADIKWS.

Here comes the famed two cents:

THEOU seems a pretty straightforward objective genitive. The rendering of the word
SUNEIDHSIS conscience or consciousness also seems straightforward.  I am not familiar
with the scholars that you cite (GOP pelt, Van Houwelingen). In reading /explaining
ID SUNEIDHIN QUEUE as "the conscience trained on God which remains bound to him"  as
being  the *basis* or *origen* of the suffering,  they seem to me to have remained
with the basic ID notion of causality or reason. The expansion given above does add a
vividness to the causality perhaps even startles a bit. It made me immediately think
of Din 17:14 even though there is no grammatical comparison.  Seems to me to be a
good reading.

Best wishes.

(Rev.) John M. Harking
St. Michael R C Church
1445 N 2nd Street
Philadelphia  Pa 19122





More information about the B-Greek mailing list