Abraham or Sara?

Steven Craig Miller scmiller at plantnet.com
Thu Dec 7 08:06:42 EST 2000


To: Iver Larsen,

<< One comment about what this phrase "literally means". The noun KATABOLH 
occurs 11 times in the NT, 10 of which are followed by KOSMOU. These ten 
refer to the creation/foundation/beginning of the world. It is therefore 
reasonable to suggest that the primary meaning of the noun is 
foundation/creation/beginning. >>

One must not forget that Greek was a living language in the 1st century CE. 
And that most Greek words (like most words in any other language) will have 
a range of meanings associated with them. Furthermore, the "primary" 
meaning of a Greek word can never be determined simply by NT usage. In 
addition, while "foundation" could be considered a "literal meaning" of 
this word, "creation" and "beginning" cannot. They are rather figurative 
extensions of the literal meaning. Instead of arguing for this word's 
"primary" meaning (whatever that might be), I would suggest trying to argue 
that "foundation" is a "common" meaning for this word (which it is). In 
fact, the argument might even be made that "foundation," and its metaphoric 
senses, are a much more "common" use for KATABOLH than the meaning "sowing" 
of sperm in the act of begetting (at least that is my sense of it from 
reading LSJM and BDAG -- not that one can always tell these things simply 
by reading a lexicon).

BDAG offers two possibilities for this passage. First DUNAMIN EIS KATABOLHN 
SPERMATOS ELABEN could mean "she received the ability to establish a 
posterity" or else our Greek text probably is in error since if KATABOLH is 
used to mean "sowing" of seed used in begetting, this expression could not 
be used of Sarah.

-Steven Craig Miller
Alton, Illinois (USA)
scmiller at plantnet.com





More information about the B-Greek mailing list