Night and Day
GregStffrd at aol.com
GregStffrd at aol.com
Tue Feb 8 11:03:17 EST 2000
In a message dated 02/08/2000 5:01:41 AM Pacific Standard Time,
behrman at email.unc.edu writes:
<< 1 Clement 27:7 gives a quotation of LXX Ps. 19:1-3, which includes the
puzzling hH hHMERA THi hHMERAi EREUGETAI RHMA KAI NUX NUKTI ANAGGELLEI
GNWSIN. A typical translation is something like "day utters speech to day
and night proclaims knowledge to night." But I have no idea what that
means (i.e., in English) (and note: I'm *not* asking what the original
Hebrew meant, but what the Greek in 1 Clement did).
What would you think of something a bit more paraphrastic that, while
still strange, can at least be construed, something like: "One day utters
a word to another, and one night proclaims knowledge to the next"?
-- Bart D. Ehrman >>
Dear Bart:
The only problem I see with your suggested translation is whether or not the
text is really suggesting that a particular day/night speaks and proclaims
knowledge to "another" DAY/NIGHT (figuratively speaking, of course). Rather,
it seems that the sense of the datives is "by day" and "by night,"
respectively, so that the idea conveyed is the regularity/consistency with
which the created heavens make known the glory and wisdom of God.
Thus, I would translate: "Day by day the firmament/sky [TO STEPEWMA] gives
forth speech [speech that DIHGOUNTAI DOXAN QEOU], and night by night it [TO
STEREWMA] proclaims [His] knowledge."
Greg Stafford
More information about the B-Greek
mailing list