continuous action
Brian Sullivan
bsullivan at dingoblue.net.au
Tue Sep 5 01:31:33 EDT 2000
Dear Frank,
Years back, when I first discovered aktionstart it was from the following
reference. I hope it helps.
It is from C D F Moules An Idiom Book of New Testament Greek on page 5
(1953, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
A. Aktionsart
The ethos of English verbs concentrates attention mainly on the time to
which an event is referredpast, present, or future. In Greek, on the other
hand, this is probably not the most fundamental question; and the
interpretation of many N.T. passages depends not a little on the
recognition that, to the Greek mind, another consideration appears to have
presented itself firstnamely the nature of the event, or (to use a German
word which has become a technical term of grammarians) the Aktionsart (the
kind of action). Generally speaking, the first question that the Greek
writer seems to ask himself is not When did (or will) this happen? but
Am I conceiving of it as protracted or as virtually instantaneous?
Moulton has represented this pictorially by popularizing the terms linear
and punctiliar to denote the two chief contrasted types of
actionprotracted like a line and focused into a point
In English the idea of protracted action can as a rule only be conveyed by
the use of some auxiliary word or words; e.g. to be releasing is a
linear phrase, while to release is (or at least may be) punctiliar;
he was releasing is linear, but he released is definitely
punctiliar. Greek, however, expresses this distinction more neatly by
altering the form of a single word; e.g. ballein (Present Infinitive) is
to be throwing, while balein (Aorist Infinitive) is simply to throw;
ballein is linear, but balein is punctiliar. Thus, the first question
to ask about a Greek verb stem is whether it expresses linear or
punctiliar Aktionsart.
It ought to be added that both in Greek and English there are some verbs
which, owing to their very meaning, can only be either linear or
punctiliar (not both). Thus, to snatch is necessarily punctiliar, and
the Imperfect, he was snatching a few moments of sleep, can, in the
nature of the case, only refer in reality to the protracted result of a
punctiliar act he was enjoying the rest which he snatched (at a given
moment punctiliar).
Brian Sullivan
-----Original Message-----
From: ArtFrankD at aol.com [mailto:ArtFrankD at aol.com]
Sent: Tuesday, 5 September 2000 7:45 AM
To: Biblical Greek
Subject: [b-greek] continuous action
I hear often aphrase which describes a continuous or on-going action, but
I
cannot find it elsewhere. The phrase is: LINEAR ACTION SART (ck spelling).
Is
it an accurate application and wording and what is its etymology? Thanks,
Art.
---
B-Greek home page: http://metalab.unc.edu/bgreek
You are currently subscribed to b-greek as: bsullivan at dingoblue.net.au
To unsubscribe, forward this message to
$subst('Email.Unsub')
To subscribe, send a message to subscribe-b-greek at franklin.oit.unc.edu
More information about the B-Greek
mailing list