Acts 2:38
DJNordlund at aol.com
DJNordlund at aol.com
Sun May 27 01:07:10 EDT 2001
In a message dated 5/26/2001 3:42:45 PM Pacific Daylight Time,
Wayne_Leman at SIL.ORG writes:
>>----- Original Message -----
>>From: "Ted Mann" <theomann at earthlink.net>
>> Is it entirely unreasonable to translate this as: "Repent... and be
>> baptized... into [i.e., into the condition of] the forgiveness of
>>sins..."?
>Wouldn't that require an EN, Ted?
>And then, unfortunately, this ordinary English speaker (me) can't understand
>that wording any better than the others suggested here on the list. I want
>to be able to understand the meaning of the Greek phrasing from an
>appropriate English translation. It is supposed to be possible, according to
>translation theory.
>Thanks for your suggestion,
>Wayne
Wayne,
I mostly just lurk because I have no formal training in Greek or in
translation theory. However, as someone with some training in cognitive
psychology as regards natural language understanding, I have been fascinated
by the various threads on this list. Part of the difficulty in providing an
"appropriate English translation" that explains the Greek phrasing for me
(apart from struggling with the Greek), and maybe for others as well, is the
reluctance to stray "too far" from the Greek text. While a paraphrase like
The Message is, for me, just too much stream of consciousness, I do not
believe a word for word translation is possible.
But back to the phrase at hand. I might begin with the somewhat literal:
"... for the forgiveness of sins."
However, that is not entirely satisfactory. In looking up EIS in my copy of
Bauer, Arndt, Gingrich, they make reference to Philemon 1:6 where they
suggest that EIS CRISTON IHSOUN (hope I have that right) probably should be
translated "in honor of Christ Jesus." I take this to be similar to saying
in English, when planning to do something noble, "I am going to do this for
my mother." That is, in honor of, or because of, my mother.
So I might take "... for the forgiveness of sins" to mean
"in honor of the forgiveness of sins", or
"because of the forgiveness of sins"
That is, we are to be baptized because our sins are forgiven. And that is
probably enough of my stream of consciousness.
Dan Nordlund
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://lists.ibiblio.org/pipermail/b-greek/attachments/20010527/d55b5025/attachment.html
More information about the B-Greek
mailing list