[B-Greek] EIS TA IDIA - John 1:11
Barry Hofstetter
nebarry at verizon.net
Fri Aug 8 07:52:12 EDT 2003
----- Original Message -----
From: "Erich Vaughan Burton" <zaxciel at hotmail.com>
To: "B-Greek" <b-greek at lists.ibiblio.org>
Sent: Friday, August 08, 2003 5:12 AM
Subject: [B-Greek] EIS TA IDIA - John 1:11
>>Robertson and Vincent both say "EIS TA IDIA"
means "unto his own things".
I understand why it is translated as "own things"
since "TA IDIA" is a plural neuter
However, in light of the passage this seemed to be too general and vague,
so I searched the Internet to see what others might have said and
I found this explanation:<<
********************************************************************************
******************
What is signified by "His own" twice repeated in this text? It reads in the
original,
"He came EIS TA IDIA and HOI IDIOI received Him not." The facts in the case
must supply the words understood. Jesus came to His own kingdom, or realm,
but His own people, the Jews, who are the "children of the kingdom,"
did not receive Him, but rejected, and crucified Him.
The reading is, then, "He came EIS TA IDIA BASILEIA into His own realm,
and HOI IDIOI LAOI His own people did not receive Him
********************************************************************************
******************
>>This seems reasonable to me and fits in with the context.
But since the commentator is adding words that are not in the
original text, I would like to know what others think regarding the
interpretation of
"EIS TA IDIA".<<
Well, I think it is an unnecessary specification of the text. One of the
advantages of using the neuter plural in such contexts is that is includes as
much as is possible to include, much as we do when we talk about "things" and
don't want to be more specific in our text. At the risk of making a more
exegetical/theological observation, *kingdom* is not as big a theme in John as
in the synoptics. Considering the "cosmic" scope of the prologue, it might be
better to take TA IDIA in the broadest possible sense, rather than restrict it
to "realm" or "kingdom."
N.E. Barry Hofstetter
Associate Pastor, CGC
Adjunct Professor, CUTS
http://mysite.verizon.net/vze1yfx7/
Moderator:
Reformed Theology Discussion
rtdisc at yahoogroups.com
Biblical Exegesis Group
bibexegesis at yahoogroups.com
More information about the B-Greek
mailing list