[B-Greek] Mark 1.14
Mark Goodacre
M.S.Goodacre at bham.ac.uk
Fri Nov 7 08:35:24 EST 2003
On 6 Nov 2003 at 5:51, Carl W. Conrad wrote:
> All this is certainly plausible, Mark, but
The "but" and what comes after suggest that I should interpret this
use of the word "plausible" in line with the immediate context as
meaning something like "possible" or "plausible-sounding but
unconvincing". Is there a difference of nuance, I wonder, between
American and British uses of the word plausible?
> (a) it's no longer a
> question about what the text must mean but rather, as you say, of
> translation and interpretation--not matters that can be resolved by
> analysis of the Greek text as a Greek text, but rather matters that
> depend upon how one understands the immediate and broader context of a
> text whose Greek sense is already reasonably clear,
Yes, though I'd want to add that I'd be wary of too marked a
distinction between "analysis of the Greek text as a Greek text" and
"translation and interpretation" -- but that's a perennial.
> and (b) I'm not
> sure it's compelling. Is JnBpt not engaged in proclamation of the
> EUAGGELION?
No, not according to Mark. I think for Mark John is preparing the
way of the Lord; it's pre-gospeling if there is such a thing.
> How are you understanding EUAGGELION IHSOU CRISTOU in Mk
> 1:1?
I'd take it as an objective genitive, Gospel of Jesus Christ i.e. the
gospel concerning him, which involves more than just the gospel that
he preached.
> EUAGGELION appears relatively rarely in Mk: Mark 1:1,14-15; 8:35;
> 10:29; 13:10; 14:9; 16:15 (I wouldn't count 16:15), and only once with
> TOU QEOU. So, although I think it's plausible, it really doesn't seem
> compelling to me. --
As above, I'm intrigued by your use of "plausible" and "compelling",
which I would more nearly equate than distinguish, though I'd also
have "compelling" as stronger than "plausible". Anyway, the fact
that EUAGGELION doesn't occur again with TOU QEOU is exactly my point
-- that Jesus has received the gospel "from God" in 1.14 and
subsequently Mark talks about the content of and preaching of that
gospel, not its origin.
Mark
-----------------------------
Dr Mark Goodacre mailto:M.S.Goodacre at bham.ac.uk
Graduate Institute for Theology & Religion
Dept of Theology
University of Birmingham
Elmfield House, Bristol Road tel.+44 121 414 7512
Birmingham B29 6LQ UK fax: +44 121 415 8376
http://www.theology.bham.ac.uk/goodacre
http://NTGateway.com
More information about the B-Greek
mailing list