[B-Greek] Was SKUBALON a swear/vulgar word?
Jim West
jwest at highland.net
Fri May 20 19:56:35 EDT 2005
Doug Hoxworth wrote:
>Do we have any evidence that this was how it
>was actually used? Or does Paul in Phil 3.8 just mean
>that his former life was
>garbage/useless/worthless/refuse? Please advise.
>
>Thank you.
>
In fact any word, if spoken with the right tone, can be derogatory.
When Paul said his former life was "dog castings" what did he mean?
Well if you have a somewhat scatological bent and you hear Paul's tone
as somewhat vulgar, its not too much of a stretch to imagine that "dog
castings" means "dog excrement" or in colloquial english, "dog crap".
But if you are more gentle in nature and can't imagine Paul's tone as
being anything other than pious, it will be nearly impossible for you to
hear anything out of order.
Personally, I think Paul was a bit wicked. To the Galatians he says "if
they think cutting off a little bit will do them any good, tell them to
hack off the whole thing!". Thus, its not too difficult for me to read
"dog crap" where others would read "refuse". Translation is art as much
as it is science. To forget that is to consistently mis-translate.
Best
Jim
--
Jim West
Biblical Studies Resources - http://web.infoave.net/~jwest
Biblical Theology Weblog - http://biblical-studies.blogspot.com
More information about the B-Greek
mailing list