[B-Greek] Modern Greek pronunciation for poetry
Carl W. Conrad
cwconrad at ioa.com
Tue Sep 20 07:35:13 EDT 2005
I might just add one other useful feature of metrical reading of
Homeric verse: part of such reading involves recognition of the
standard caesurae in the line and that helps one to see the
architecture of Homeric verse -- the way the formulae first expounded
in Milman Parry's epochal studies operate, e.g.
MHNIN/ AEIDE QEA/ PHLHIADEW/ ACILHOS
OULOMENHN, hH MURI(A) ACAIOIS/ ALGE(A) EQHKEN ...
There's the power of the word order: the opening hexameter beginning
with MHNIN, the very theme of the epic and closing with the majestic
drawn-out epithet and name of the epic's hero, Achilles; then there's
the powerful participial-adjectival adjective OULOMENHN in the
opening colon of line 2, which as a unit characterizes the MHNIN
enunciated in the first colon of line 1; thereupon there's the neat
expression MURI(A) ACAIOIS -- "countless to the Achaeans"
highlighting the dative of recipient of the griefs all in a compact
phrase hH MURI' ACAIOIS, then following the pause of the so-called
bucolic diaeresis, the thudding predicate, ALGE(A) EQHKEN. Rhythmic
reading of Homer, I am personally convinced, is essential to
appreciating the intricate art of Homeric verse.
On Sep 20, 2005, at 6:57 AM, Jeremy D. Brightbill wrote:
> Bert de Haan wrote: "Obviously I am in a different league than
> either one of
> you, (I am a boy scout and not a marine.) If I try to read it in
> meter I
> have no idea what I am reading. I have not found that the hexameter
> sustains itself in my mind. I would love to hear someone read a
> page or so
> of the Iliad with an organ in the background playing the pitch and
> the vowel
> length. I enjoy reading the Iliad without getting the meter but it
> would be
> great if "getting" the meter would increase the enjoyment.
> Bert de Haan."
>
> Oh, you would enjoy it ten times more with the meter! I don't know
> where I
> fit on the Boy Scout to Marine continuum :) but I've found that
> learning to
> read Homer with the meter is *definitely* worth the investment. In
> Homer,
> the meter is everything! (Perhaps an overstatement, but
> still....) The
> poems were originally oral compositions, and the bards would
> improvise on
> the spot as they stood before the audience. This was possible
> because they
> started with a pool of stock phrases that would fit at different
> parts of
> the hexameter line. A lot of the phrases don't have much meaning in
> themselves, but you see the genius of the poet as you read line
> after line
> and see how he fits the phrases into the metrical system to carry
> the story
> forward.
> As others have mentioned, it's quite difficult to read the Iliad
> with pitch and vowel length, but it's not so hard to pronounce the
> verse
> ictus as stress. I used Clyde Pharr's "Homeric Greek" textbook,
> and he
> recommends memorizing the first 50 lines of the Iliad in order to
> get the
> meter in your head. That worked really well for me.
> This might be getting off-topic for B-Greek, so I'll just mention
> two sites that have good resources: www.aoidoi.org and
> www.textkit.com. The
> latter has a discussion forum for people who are learning Homeric
> Greek.
>
> Jeremy Brightbill
>
>
>
> ---
> B-Greek home page: http://metalab.unc.edu/bgreek
> B-Greek mailing list
> B-Greek at lists.ibiblio.org
> http://lists.ibiblio.org/mailman/listinfo/b-greek
>
Carl W. Conrad
Department of Classics, Washington University (Emeritus)
1989 Grindstaff Road/Burnsville, NC 28714/(828) 675-4243
cwconrad2 at mac.com
WWW: http://www.ioa.com/~cwconrad/
More information about the B-Greek
mailing list