[B-Greek] Agent in JOHN 6:19b
Elizabeth Kline
kline_dekooning at earthlink.net
Sun Mar 4 16:53:23 EST 2007
On Mar 4, 2007, at 12:28 AM, Iver Larsen wrote:
> For GINOMAI, the primary role is Patient, with the potential for an
> additional role of Agent, both
> roles referring to the syntactic subject. It is a descriptive verb
> that does not focus on Jesus
> walking on the water, but his position being at or changing toward
> the vicinity of the boat, so
> "getting near the boat" would catch the meaning nicely.
>
> By the way, predicate adjectives function very much the same way as
> descriptive verbs like "be" or
> "become". In some languages you don't say "She is beautiful", you
> say "she beautifuls". The semantic
> frame is the same: one Patient role. When you describe something,
> the thing you describe has the
> role of Patient. In an African language that I am familiar with,
> you can put both person and tense
> prefixes on adjectives in the same way they are attached to verbs.
JOHN 6:19 ELHLAKOTES OUN hWS STADIOUS EIKOSI PENTE H TRIAKONTA
QEWROUSIN TON IHSOUN PERIPATOUNTA EPI THS QALASSHS KAI EGGUS TOU
PLOIOU GINOMENON, KAI EFOBHQHSAN.
Iver,
I think my first response sort of missed your point which is a
typical problem in these discussions. My reading of Danker 3rd Ed on
GINOMAI gave me the impression that GINOMAI is capable of being used
to describe a process/activity. See Danker 198-199 #6 "to make a
change of location in space, move". If we understand KAI EGGUS TOU
PLOIOU GINOMENON in Jn 6:19 as describing a state and only a state
"near the boat" then I would agree that there isn't any room for a
semantic agent.
But the structure of the verse also had a role in my understanding
GINOMAI as describing activity.
IHSOUN
PERIPATOUNTA EPI THS QALASSHS
KAI
EGGUS TOU PLOIOU GINOMENON
I understood this Xism as being two expressions defining the same
ACTIVITY with the same semantic agent as defined in my previous reply.
Anyway, I think I can see why everyone is objecting to the agent role
for this verse.
thanks for all the responses, Carl is right about the metalanguage
problem.
Elizabeth Kline
More information about the B-Greek
mailing list