[B-Greek] Update on Greek aspect, semantics and pragmatics

Randall Buth randallbuth at gmail.com
Sun May 15 05:45:18 EDT 2011


XAIre KonstaNTINE χαῖρε Κονσταντίνε

Konstantinos egrapse
> I do NOT hold to "aspect only" for anything, and differ to Porter
> on this quite dramatically.

This is intriguing. I could use the same words myself when talking
about indicatives.

Regarding the Greek outworking of your point above, a brief update
on some or all of the following questions might be helpful on list.

1. Would you now agree that the "historical present" is a
rhetorical/pragmatic usage in Greek whose [pragmatic/rhetorical]
effect requires it to be used 'against its basic semantics'?
Cf. a recent thread, "Why is the aspect of the historic present
'against its grain'?" (Answering on the other thread would allow us
to focus on just that question.)

2. Would you say that the aorist indicative carries the 'foreground'
in Greek narrative genre?
(If not, would you care to comment on the story in point 4?)

3. Do you now think that the aorist and imperfect Indicatives,
e.g, EPOIHSE, EPOIEI carry a semantic feature of "+past time"
along with their aspectual features?

4. In other words, isn't the Porterite "metaphor of remoteness" a
roundabout way of talking about past time, in both its semantic
and pragmatic uses, without mentioning time?
(We never add e- to futures to mark them "remote futures", or to
any non-indicatives. And by 'remote', we NEVER mean spatially
remote. It does not mark real world 'distance', ever. Which makes
it an opaque, disingenuous metaphor for things that have 95-100%
temporal congruency.
In the example in the 'against the grain' thread, Mk 8.22-26, the
touching, looking, and restoration, were not spatially far away
but 'right there' AND they were the main, central events of the story,
something textlinguists call 'foreground'. Certainly not remote or
marginal. The imperfectives have natural 'backgrounded'
interpretations.)
(and Yes, not a few linguists think that semantic features can
have pragmatic usages.)

>Thanks

You're welcome,
and thank you.

It would be nice to drop by the 505 (for some Greek and jazz).

ἔρρωσο ERRWSO

Ἰωάνης IWANHS (I like to 'misspell' my name like Westcott-Hort
and a 1st century ossuary here in the Rockefeller musuem.)


-- 
Randall Buth, PhD
www.biblicallanguagecenter.com
Biblical Language Center
Learn Easily - Progress Further - Remember for Life


More information about the B-Greek mailing list