There is no doubt that the Humate or Humic acid market is clouded with
credability. It earned its 'snake oil' image through blown up claims and lack
of quality control.
Having said that, there are definate benefits in using humic acids in one's
growing operation. All brown liquids are not the same. The factors effecting
the quality and efficacy of a humic acid have to do with the source of ore
from which it was mined and the extraction process employed. There is
validity to the calims of proprietary processes.
Since humic acids are not one defined molecule but rather a group of carbon
chains they must be charactorized by size and the quantity and type of
functional groups attached to that chain. These materials because they are
basic in nature do have some handling issues associated with them. The
industry over time has made humic acids more friendly by creating soluble
powders and liquids that are compatable with most nutritional; sprays. The
problem is they have, in the same time, processed out the bulk of their
activity! Data presented concerning humics must be specific for each
formulation.
The very substances that require a quality humic acid to be handled in a
particular manner and can cause mixing and application problems if not
handled properly. They are also the substances we want to have in our soil.
Be very cautious of humic acids whose major benfit is compatability and ease
of use.
There are excellent products on the US market from US deposits. These have
low salt indexes, few contaminants. a good portion of small molecular weight
humic acids and consistant quality control.
Buyer bewre. If the price of a humate or humic acid seems too good to be
true, it probably is.
If anyone wants more information, they can e-mail me direct and I will try to
answer any questions I can.
Tom
To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
compost_tea-unsubscribe_at_yahoogroups.com
Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to
http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
.
Received on Fri Nov 01 2002 - 12:25:19 EST