[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: [compost_tea] Fwd: compost tea applications - persistance
1. Does the customer benefit from CT applied in the fall as soil drench?
If the organisms survive addition to the soil. What if you have toxic residues in the soil?
What if you don't have food to feed the organisms in the soil? Add CT to straight sand, no OM, and the organisms don't survive.
If we made you jump out of a plane and you landed in ghost town, NV, would you survive? Should we then conclude that people can't survive through the winter in NV?
Please, think things through.
2. Does the customer benefit from CT injection under a mulch or 3 to 12 inches in depth in permeable soils under and around fruit trees and other long life plants?.
If the soil has no life to begin, of course. If the soil is lacking in certain sets of organisms provided by CT, then of course.
But what if the soil is healthy, fully functioning, and everyone is already there? Will you see a benefit of CT? Probably not. No harm, but no benefit.
3. Will the CT microbial life persist/ increase from fall to spring when applied in the fall?
Yes, if you think of the critters are being like yourself. They need food, protection,
good conditions to grow and reproduce. If you don't give them enough time to establish a condominium before the bad guys arrive, or the winter weather gets bad, then you won't see any persistence, because just like people, they will die if they can't get colonization going.
4. Will CT microbial life continue in the soil, growing and increasing with time?
Given the same thought processes as above.....
5. Or is it necessary to re-apply CT a frequent intervals because the microbes simply die off in the soil?
If you have toxic chemicals, you have to re-apply until the toxin is decomposed. But what about air pollution? That will take organisms out, no matter what. So, in the middle of a city, you will always have to put organisms back. What about the middle of Skagit Valley? Well, what's the pollution load? Did anyone up-wind of you apply a chemical that may have killed some of your good guys? Then you need to re-apply......
Microbes in soil die off for the same reason people die. Something kills them. There is no evidence that organisms die of "old age" in the soil. Something kills them. They may be eaten by protozoa, nematodes or microarthropods. They may die from lack of food. No space. Inhibitory compounds may get them. Chemicals. Air pollution.
Compost will benefit compacted clay soils and lend water retention ability to sandy soil. But
CT acts the same in a clay soil than a sand soil. The organisms form aggregates. In a clay soil, it is the microaggregates that are very important, so water can move
at a reasonable rate in the soil. In a sand soil, it is bacteria gluing the sand particulate together that make aggregates, and form "dams" that then begin to hold water, slowing water down and increasing water holding capacity. So, the organisms in CT do the same things in soil - make aggregates, but with quite different spatial scales in different soils. But in all cases, the organisms work to make soil structure hold water, nutrients and air so plants are benefited
If CT is applied - soil drench - to those same soils will it have similar effect even tho it may take more time and depend on the plants to add fiber / mulch to the soil?
If CT as a drench on the soil, the microbes thrive and multiply, why would successive applications be advised?
Both replies require that you think about the fact that organisms need food. If you have good food in the soil, the organisms will do their job rapidly and efficiently. If the soil is poor in foods, the organisms will struggle and may not do their job.
It's up to us to feed the good guys.
When would CT be useful as a dormant spray?
When the conditions are such that the organisms won't wake up for awhile. When you have to transport the organisms over some distance. But that's not a good idea. You want indigenous organisms, not organisms that are adapted to a different climate or weather regime. So, put-to-sleep organisms aren't going to be all that useful, unless you can document that the put-to-sleep organisms are the really beneficial species that are not present in your soil.
And on what type plants?
Why would there be some plants that like dormant organisms?
Hope these help.
Elaine
President, Soil Foodweb Inc.
www.soilfoodweb.com
To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
compost_tea-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com
Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service.