[Prev][Next][Index][Thread]
Re: Ecological Economics and Entropy
yuku@io.org (Yuri Kuchinsky) wrote:
>David Lloyd-Jones (dlj@inforamp.net) wrote:
>
>: Jay,
>:
>: I think you're losing it. It is finally sinking in on you that all
>: your pseudo-science impresses nobody -- particularly nobody in the
>: fields into which you intrude as a loud poseur. As a result you
>: thrash around as above, without logic, without manners, without
>: dignity.
>
>This is totally unfair, David. How about talking about substance and
>leaving personalities alone?
The substance here is Jay's previous post, which you have mercifully
snipped.
>Pseudo-science is in the eye of the beholder, surely. Jay always bases his
>views on substantial research.
This is not true. Jay's footnotes are often phrased in a way which
makes it appear that a named person is an author when in fact the name
given is the title of another screed by Jay himself. I.e. the
"substantial research" is merely the repetition of his earlier
opinions.
> There must be a way to disagree with
>someone and yet respect them as an individual.
It is very difficult to respect a propagandist as single-mindedly
dishonest as Hanson. Such a person deserves an individually crafted
disrespect.
-dlj.
References: