You are here: SriPedia - SriRangaSri - Archives - Jul 2003

SriRangaSri List Archive: Message 00107 Jul 2003

 
Jul 2003 Indexes ( Date | Thread | Author )
[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next]


SrI:


Sub: With reference to my previous email titled " SADDENING AND UNHEALTHY". 
( which was a reply to sri sudarshan's " the one and the many" email)

I thought I would give here the slokam of swami desikan that was mentioned in 
my previous mail. This is from paradevathapaaramaarthyaadhikaaram of Srimad 
Rahasya Traya Saram.


"Athmaikyam daivathaikyam thrikasamadhigataa tulyataikyam trayANAm
anyatraishvaryamithyAdhyanipuNa -phanithIrAdriyantE na santa:
thraiyantairEkakantaistadanuguna-manu-vyAsa-mukyOkthibhishcha
srImAnArayanO na: pathirAkilatanurmukthidO mukthabhOgya:"


Meanings:

Athmaikyam : " All atmaas are same only. there is no difference"
daivathaikyam: : "All Gods are same"
thrikasamadhigataa tulyata : " all the 3 mummoorthis are same w.r.t jnana and 
other qualities"

trayAnAm ikyam: " all the 3 of the mumoorthies have same aathma swaroopam

anyatraishvaryam: " there is someone else supreme than these 3 mumoorthis"

ithyAdhi: all these words 

(of)

anipuNa -phanithI : F O O L S

na AdhriyanthE : will be discarded (by)

santa: " those who can distinguish between sAram & asAram" (i.e by those who 
can distinguish the invaluable from junk)

pause...

Ekakantai: In one voice 

thraiyantai: Upanishads

tadanuguna-manu-vyAsa-mukyOkthibhishcha : and the srisookthis of manu, vyasa 
which are consistent with upanishads

( asserts that)

srimAn Narayana: " Sriman Narayana i.e srIvishishta narayanan or "agalagillEn 
iraiyumendru alarmElmangai uraimArbhan"


AkilatanurmukthidO mukthabhOgya: (is the one who) has everything as His 
sharIram and the one who grants moksham and the one who is enjoyed by mukthAs.

(also He is )


pathi : sEshI

na: for us.


This was the slokam of Swami Desikan that I was alluding to. So this shows that 
the "oneness theory" is non-sense as far as Vedantham and thus SrI Vedantha 
Desikan is concerned. So do not include him in the list of " mahAns" that u 
have mentioned.

Stronger arguements against your philosophy can be found in Sri BhAshyam, 
Satadhooshani and ParamArtha Bhooshanam. ( All these are real nightmares for 
those belonging to the " oneness" school of thought)


I request you not to take recourse to bits and pieces of my email to support a 
philosophy that does not belong to Sri Sampradayam.


PadhukAdAsan,
AravindalOchanadAsAnudAsan.





---------------------------------
Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! SiteBuilder - Free, easy-to-use web site design software

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]





[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next] [Date Index ] [Thread Index ] [Author Index ]
Home Page
http://www.ibiblio.org/sripedia
srirangasri-subscribe@yahoogroups.com
To subscribe to the list