From: jasn sn [jayasartn@xxxxxxxxx]
Sent: Saturday, November 27, 2004 10:13 AM
Subject: Re: Bow's story ? further clarifications on questions
raised.
JASN: SrI: Respected sri Vasudevan swami, Thank you for your mail. I
look forward to your comments. Meanwhile I thought I can share some
more views.
MGV: Welcome.
JASN: This is about Brahmasthram. On the one side we see that the
brahmasthram sent by Indrajit could only tie up Hanuman (Sundhara
khandam) and on the other, we find that Rama delayed (?) the use of
it till he got tired (?) of cutting Ravana's head. He is said to have
weighed the options of what asthra to use and then decided to shoot
the Brahmasthra.
MGV: sri hanumaan had the boon by brahmaa, that all weapons including
his own brahmaasthram cannot do any harm to hanumaan. Just to show
respect to pithaamahan, the athidhEvathaa for that asthram, that too
in front of others, hanumaan waited as though he was bound. Also,
that was a pretext, so that, if, a chance comes in his way, he could
see that so called mighty raavaNan. That chance eventually came in
his way. This is fully explained in sundhara kaaNdam.
JASN: Also we see repeatedly that Rama always applies discretion as
to what asthras to use. A blade of grass became his asthra to punish
kaakaasura, but that he waited for a while to decide on to use
brahmasthra is a point to ponder.
MGV: For kaakaasuran ? it is immediate punishment ? for, he has done
physical damage to raamaa's wife, that too in front of raamaa and in
the vicinity of raamaa. Further his identity at that stage may be a
point, since he is a dhEvaa. For dhEvaas, no hesitation is shown by
raamaa in punishing them.
As said in vaali's slain by sri anjaneyalu, vaali made a heavy
mistake of making friendship with raavaNan. Similarly the son of king
of dhEvaas, jayanthan, who is kaakaasuran, has to be severely
punished for the crime. Further he did not have brahmaa's boons like
raavaNan.
Also as said in manu smruthi the `punishment levels' for the same
type of crime, to people among the chaathur varNam vary. The severest
is for BraahmaNan ?1st varnam and lightest for the 4th varnam. Since
jayanthan is one more than the 1st varnam itself, viz. dhEvaa, the
punishment level to him has to be naturally higher than braahmaNan.
He has to receive severest punishment, that too immediately, that is
what happened in jayanthan's case.
For raavaNan it is with a hesitation. For brahma only had given the
boon to raavaNan. Perhaps raama had the doubt of whether brahma's own
asthram will work against brahmaa's own `boon recipient', the
raavaNan.
But since shooter is somebody else, presently raama, who is the super
lord of brahma himself, the servant brahma has to do his duty / job,
as well his asthram. Or otherwise also brahmaasthram is forced to do
that assigned job of killing raavaNan, since command is by the
supreme lord.
JASN: I deduce that in the case of Hanuman [irrespective of the curse
(or boon?) (or I consider the boons and curses only to reinforce the
already pending result)] had that he would be bound by Brahmasthra
for 1 muhoortha kaalam, the Brahmasthra was powerless against him, in
view of his being protected by Dharma and exalted virtues. Applying
the same yardstick, the Brahmasthra, if used earlier on Ravana would
not have vanquished him, with some dharma still sticking to him and
protecting him. Rama seemed to have waited for the right moment to
use it.
MGV: comment already given above.
JASN: A corollary can be found in Karna's demise. Again Karna's use
of Brahmasthra on Arjuna, would not have resulted in the demise of
Arjuna even if the Lord were not to be physically present, by the
logic that arjuna was still shielded with dharma. This may also be
the reason why the asthra could not meet the target (Arjuna) (Dharma
in the form of Krishna protected him). Because we get to hear that
these asthras are precision-driven not by physical aiming but by some
manthras. Once shot, the asthra would certainly find its target. But
that it could not in Arjuna's case (though by the curse that karna
had) may be primarily to do with the strength of the target and the
kind of protection that the target enjoys. I wish to see you take up
a write-up on Brahmasthras as found in the two epics for better
understanding for all of us. regards, jayasree saranathan
MGV: as stated I will take up this separately.
Dhaasan
Vaasudevan m.g.
------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor --------------------~-->
$4.98 domain names from Yahoo!. Register anything.
http://us.click.yahoo.com/Q7_YsB/neXJAA/yQLSAA/VkWolB/TM
--------------------------------------------------------------------~->
Yahoo! Groups Links
<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/SriRangaSri/
<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
SriRangaSri-unsubscribe@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
|
Home Page
http://www.ibiblio.org/sripedia |
srirangasri-subscribe@yahoogroups.com To subscribe to the list |