Mt. 18:3

Maurice A. O'Sullivan mauros at iol.ie
Fri Aug 20 06:43:30 EDT 1999


In Mt. 18:3, there occurs STRAFHTE -- 2nd aorist subjunctive passive of STREFW
As I began to look at the change from E to A, I saw that BAGD lists this 
2nd aorist passive as occurring ( in addition to Homer ) in pap., LXX, and 
several examples from Josephus.

This might lead one to think that this was a Koine form, or at least 
something that emerged around the turn of the era --- at least I might have 
<g> had I not turned to Smyth s.586 where I find this note:

b. Liquid stems of one syllable change e to a,
                     as te-ta-mai, e-ta-thên (teinô stretch, ten-). But
                     strephô turn, trepô turn, trephô nourish have
                     estrephthên, etrephthên, ethrephthên (rare),
                     though the perfect middles are estrammai,
                     tetrammai, tethrammai.

                     586 b. D. estraphthên is Ionic and Doric; Hom.
                     and Hdt. have etraphthên from trepô. Hom. has
                     etarphthên and eterphthên from terpô gladden.

[ as you can see I have left the Perseus transliteration intact ]

Which raises a more general query:
How much of what might be seen as Koine forms are in fact the persistence 
of long-standing dialect forms which in course of time and usage 
predominate over "pure" Attic
( = literary ? ) forms?

Perhaps Carl, Edgar et al.  might have examples that come to mind --- I 
don't expect any sweeping generalisations from scholars <g>

A subsidiary query, on the specific verse:
The widespread translations
RSV, NAB:   "Truly, I say to you, unless you turn and ....
NRSV: "Truly I tell you, unless you change

turns the passive into an active, to accommodate the English usage.
Why not a middle form, rather than a passive, in the original, I wonder?

BTW,  in the Matthean use of " turn " I detect a very direct connection 
with the OT use of SHUV, literally "turn", in the physical sense, for the 
idea of repentance which in Greek becomes METANOIA, an intellectual concept.

Regards,
Maurice


Maurice A. O'Sullivan
[ Bray, Ireland ]
mauros at iol.ie

Confucius said: "To study and not think is a waste. To think and not study
is dangerous."
Analects 2:15




More information about the B-Greek mailing list