[B-Greek] Caragounis' book
Dr. Don Wilkins
drdwilkins at sbcglobal.net
Sat Nov 27 15:49:03 EST 2004
On Saturday, November 27, 2004, at 05:31 AM, Barry Hofstetter wrote:
> ...
> When I was an undergraduate, way back in the 20th century, we would
> occasionally get a native Hellene in our Greek classes, particularly if
> it were something relatively easy, like Xenophon or the NT. These
> folks were looking for easy elective credits (not where most American
> students would find them!). It quickly became clear that they were no
> more or less proficient than any American student, and that in fact
> their knowledge of modern Greek was occasionally a hindrance rather
> than a help, particularly when it came to vocabulary items similar in
> form to modern Greek, but with quite different semantic range. For a
> Hellene to learn ancient Greek is like a native speaker of English
> learning to read Beowulf... I agree with your comments on the
> relationship between Koine and Attic. The differences would be roughly
> equivalent to the differences between current and Elizabethan English.
> When we read documents from that period, we recognize it as English,
> but really strange at times...
>
> N.E. Barry Hofstetter
> B.A., Ancient Studies, Univ. of Maryland, 1981
> M.A. Classics, Ohio State Univ. 1986
> M.Div., Pastoral Emphasis, Westminster Theo. Sem., 1989
> Th.M., NT Studies, WTS, 1991
> Ph.D. F.E.
>
I had a similar experience in which one of my classmates was a native
Greek, and the teacher (Peter Colaclides) was known for his familiarity
with all stages of the language. He and this student would sometimes
carry on brief conversations in modern Greek, so I couldn't really tell
whether modern Greek was more of a help than a hindrance. Also, at times
it seemed that the professor was spending much more time than necessary
over a construction, but that may just be due to the fact that he
savored the language.
As a teacher (this is a favorite story), I once had a student from
Greece who had come to the states to learn classical Greek because
(according to him) it wasn't being taught at university in Greece
anymore. I frequently asked him for comparisons between Attic and
modern, but I don't remember his answers as being enlightening; then
again, he was not a particularly good student.
Don Wilkins
More information about the B-Greek
mailing list