[B-Greek] James 4:14 OITINES with 2nd person verb
Elizabeth Kline
kline-dekooning at earthlink.net
Mon Jan 2 00:32:29 EST 2006
On Jan 1, 2006, at 6:23 PM, Scott Wells wrote:
> (13) AGE NUN OI LEGONTES SHMERON H AUPION POREUSOMEQA EIS THNDE THN
> POLIN
> KAI POIHSOMEN EKEI ENIAUTON KAI EMPOREUSOMEQA KAI KERDHSOMEN (14)
> hOITINES
> OUK EPISTASQE TO THS AUPION POIA hH ZWH hUMWN ATMIS GAR ESTE hH
> PROS OLIGON
> FAINOMENH EPEITA KAI AFANIZOMENH
>
> I am not sure what to make of hOITINES with the 2nd person verb
> EPISTASQE.
> My first thought was to render the phrase "You, who do not know
> (the what
> of) tomorrow, what is your life?
>
> But upon checking several Eng translations I saw that none followed
> this
> rendering. Even the editor's punctuation of the GNT (a semicolon)
> seems to
> argue against it. Porter renders the verse "you by your very
> nature do not
> know" arguing for the essential use of OSTIS (Idioms, 133). How
> should this
> verse be understood?
>
> Scott Wells
hOITINES points back to OI LEGONTES. AGE NUN (v.13a) marks what
follows as direct address which explains the use of the second person
EPISTASQE.
Elizabeth Kline
More information about the B-Greek
mailing list