Re: John 2.4

Date: Tue Mar 12 1996 - 19:55:57 EST

In a message dated 96-03-12 02:45:44 EST, Richard Arthur wrote:

> In John 2.4, Jesus has some querulous remarks to make to his mother: TI
>EMOI KAI COI, GYNAI . . . . Although Walter Bauer says that the vocative
>GYNAI "is by no means a disrespectful form of address,
> But could someone provide me with a decent (non-confrontational)
>translation of John 2.4?
> Richard Arthur Merrimack NH

I have long suspected that this is a Hebraism. The Hebrew NT renders this as
*mah-liy walak 'ishah* which literally would be "What is there to me and you,
woman?" But this is a Hebrew idiom for "What would you have of me, woman?"
This was a polite way of saying "What would you have me do, woman?"
I suspect that there are many more Hebraisms in the NT than we realize.
James D. Price
James D. Price, Ph.D.
Prof. of Hebew and OT
Temple Baptist Seminary
Chattanooga, TN 37404

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.1.4 : Sat Apr 20 2002 - 15:37:39 EDT